A car has chronic clutch failure due to breakage of the hub from the clutch plate. Who is correct about the possible causes?

The assertion that both technicians are correct highlights the complexity of diagnosing chronic clutch failure. In cases of repeated clutch hub breakage, there are several factors that could lead to this issue, and it's plausible that both technicians have identified legitimate causes.

One possible cause that both technicians might discuss is the alignment of the clutch components. If the alignment is off, it can lead to unequal wear and increased stress on the clutch hub, making it more susceptible to breakage. Additionally, improper installation could lead to an uneven distribution of forces, exacerbating wear and ultimately resulting in failure.

Another factor to consider could be the material quality or fatigue of the clutch components. If substandard materials are used, they may not withstand the stresses encountered during normal operation. This would again support the idea that both technicians could point to the quality and condition of the components as contributing to ongoing failures.

Additionally, driving habits could be another reason both technicians are correct. Aggressive driving, frequent clutch engagement and disengagement, or improper shifting techniques could all place undue stress on the clutch system, leading to premature wear and failure of the hub.

Recognizing that multiple factors can lead to a recurring issue like clutch hub breakage illustrates the complexity of automotive diagnostics. Both technicians could be addressing valid concerns